Cell-based bioassay solutions for food contaminant testing



Project Lead
Challenges
The food supply chain is subject to potential contamination with natural and industrial toxins. Food can contain pathogenic microorganisms, natural toxic compounds or industrial chemicals added intentionally or accidentally. While acute food poisoning is relatively rare, long-term effects of food toxins are an area of concern and, therefore, routine testing of foods at different stages of agrifood processes is legally required.
Toxin testing is typically carried out using analytic methods like high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) or liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LCMS), using commercially available standards, or immunological methods. Chemical and immunological analyses are very specific and typically detect a single analyte. Targeted LCMS also requires standards for the toxins under analysis.
The number of toxins with distinct chemistry, but similar toxicity, is often substantial. For example, there are 300 different known mycotoxins and 700 different pyrrolizidines. The related substances can be produced by the same pathogenic organism or by the metabolism of the toxin and may escape detection by normal analytical techniques. For some toxins, therefore, separate tests exist for the original and the metabolised toxin. Thus, it is impossible to test for such a wide range of mycotoxins using antibodies or LCMS.
Cell-based assays
Cell-based assays utilise whole cells as indicators of a specific biological process and can be used to detect chemicals which elicit toxicity. Cell-based assays can measure a variety of biological outcomes utilising parameters, including cell viability, transcriptional changes or signalling events involving protein-protein interactions. Cell-based analysis of signalling interactions can lead to the development of immunological tests, biochemical assays, and biosensors.
Cell-based assays are used in the pharmaceutical sector for pre-clinical screening of novel therapeutic compounds but have also been used for food toxicity testing. Examples include grain-borne mycotoxins, packaging-derived xenobiotics, shellfish toxins, or pyrrolizidine alkaloids in herbal extracts. Cell-based assays can simply measure cell viability (including toxicity or, conversely, growth stimulation by endocrine activity) but can also interrogate specific signalling events affected by toxins. Whole-cell bioassays based on bacterial cells, yeast and nematodes have been developed and are used for the detection of food and environmental toxins in some commercial settings. Cell-based assays can provide an alternative for and a complement to immunological and chemical testing. As for these established techniques toxin detection is influenced by food matrices.
The advantages of cell-based assays include:
- Automatic incorporation of bioavailability and viability testing.
- Ability to test for a group of chemicals with a similar toxicity profile.
- Ability to identify toxins for which no established standards currently exist.
- This is an active area of research, and the full potential of cell-based assays has not been fully realised yet.
Questions
Solutions
The overall objective of the project is to develop cell-based assays based on the toxicity mechanism of toxins to complement the existing chemical and immunological tests. The assays are expected to enable the detection of masked toxins and toxin metabolites.
Cell-based assays for mycotoxin detection
Mycotoxins are a major hazard in the food chain. The term mycotoxin includes a wide variety of fungus-derived toxins with a variety of mechanisms of toxicity. Humans and animals can be affected by mycotoxin poisoning in response to acute and chronic exposure. Cell-based assays for mycotoxin detection have concentrated on cell viability and endocrine receptor activation in the specific case of zearalenone.
We are utilising 3 parallel approaches to develop cell-based assay systems for mycotoxins. They are based on two established toxicity responses (immune toxicity and food refusal toxicity) and one novel approach utilising the transcriptional response in a cell type which has shown high sensitivity to mycotoxin treatment. The cell-based assays have diagnostic relevance on their own, but they also inform the development of novel immunological and biosensor detection approaches by identifying undetected masked mycotoxin variants which share toxicity patterns with currently regulated compounds.
The development of these assay systems is primarily focusing on toxins currently relevant for the Scottish agri-food sector, but this approach can also be extended to include toxins which may become problems in the future due to climate change, an altered trade environment and testing requirements due to the UK’s European Union Exit, and the development of novel foods and food contact materials as a consequence of a focus on sustainability, increased biodiversity and a circular economy.
Project Partners
Progress
2023 / 2024
Mycotoxins are of relevance for human and animal health if they fulfil two criteria. They are chemically and biologically stable and they are efficiently absorbed into humans and animals through the gut membrane (i.e., they have high “bioavailability). Unstable mycotoxins or those which are not taken up into the body typically do not lead to any adverse effects.
In nature mycotoxins are modified chemically by plants or bacteria or other fungi. These modifications include oxidation, de-epoxidation or the addition of glucose or acetyl groups. Some of these chemical modifications influence how easily the mycotoxin is taken up into the cell. Other chemical modification influence how toxic the mycotoxin is.
Our data show that some chemical derivatives of deoxynivalenol (e.g., nivalenol) retain their toxicity but show reduced bioavailability. Other derivatives (e.g., the de-epoxide DOM1) are absorbed effectively, but have lost their toxicity. Glucuronidated deoxynivalenol (carrying a glucose attached to the toxin) shows very poor bioavailability and therefore has negligible toxicity. However, some of these chemical modifications (e.g. glucuronidation) can be reversed by the gut microbiome, which can reactivate the toxin.
We have also assessed the effect of the mycotoxins deoxynivalenol and T2 on the oxidative stress response in mammalian cells. Several publications seemed to suggest that DON activates this stress response pathway. However, our data suggest that DON and T2 do not show an oxidative effect. Rather they activate a stress response pathway mediated by the aryl hydrocarbon receptor (Ahr). That pathway increases the expression of the protein Nrf2. While Nrf2 is a prerequisite for the response to oxidative stress, its expression does not constitute an oxidative cell stress response.
We have also explored the ribotoxic response to trichothecene mycotoxins in more detail. We asked the question whether an increase in the amount of ribotoxicity signalling molecules (specifically, the proteins ZAK-alpha and p38) in a mammalian cell can increase the response to mycotoxin exposure. In HEK293 cells, a popular cell culture model, this is not the case. This suggests that a sufficient amount of these two stress signalling molecules is already present in HEK293 cells to mediate a maximum response to DON exposure. Whether this is also true in other cell lines will be assessed in further experiments.
Overall, the data demonstrate that cell-based bioassays are able to report on [a] the uptake of toxins into cells and on [b] different stress responses which can be combined to develop sensitive and specific assays for mycotoxin detection. The cell-based assays will also be able to detect novel mycotoxins or toxin derivatives which are currently not fully characterised.
2022 / 2023
The food chain is subject to potential contamination with natural and industrial toxins. While acute food poisoning is relatively rare, long-term effects of food toxins are an area of concern and therefore routine testing of foods at different stages of agrifood processes is legally required (EU regulation 1881/2006). Toxin testing is typically carried out using chemical analysis methods (e.g., HPLC or LCMS) using commercially available standards, or immunological methods (e.g., ELISA or lateral flow assays).
The number of toxins with distinct chemistry, but similar toxicity, is often substantial. Mycotoxins is the collective description of a wide variety of chemicals which are secreted by a multitude of fungi. However, mycotoxins can by chemically modified by other organisms generating a group of agents with similar toxicity but different chemical properties. Some of these related substances may escape detection by the conventional analytical techniques.
The objective of this project is to develop cell assays which detect the harmful properties of toxins rather than their chemical structure. The assays can complement the existing chemical and immunological test. These cell-based assays can be carried out in conjunction with microbial biotransformation treatments and therefore permit the detection of masked toxins and toxin metabolites.
The current focus of the project is on mycotoxins which are of relevance to the Scottish agri-food industry and are a consequence of mould growth (especially on cereals). The current research approach seeks to identify cell types which have high sensitivity to mycotoxins and to assess which toxicity mechanisms have the best potential for rapid and sensitive toxin detection.
Historically the ingestion of mouldy foods containing mycotoxins led to food refusal and immune suppression. The prevalent mycotoxin deoxynivalenol is therefore also known colloquially as vomitoxin. The biochemical mechanisms which underly these toxic effects were tested as indicators of mycotoxin exposure in candidate cell lines. Candidate reporter systems were developed and tested. In addition, a comprehensive database analysis systematically appraised the currently available raw data on cellular responses to mycotoxin exposure (see publications and other outputs).
Our results demonstrate that one of the mechanisms of toxicity (called ribotoxicity) provides a rapid and sensitive readout for mycotoxin exposure in mammalian cell lines. This can be exploited for the development of robust cell-based assay systems.
Publications and other outputs
A science brief: Detection of mycotoxins using cell-based assays
A sytematic review of mycotoxin transcriptomics describing the available evidence for trichothecene mycotoxin effects in mammalian cells
Previous Projects
Related Projects
Food Safety
The focus of the work is on microbial contaminants of food, either directly or via toxins, and heavy metal contaminants. The work will define risk factors and improve detection of the most important food-borne pathogens, toxins and heavy metals, and will examine the flow of antimicrobial resistance through the food and into the commensal microbiota, all of which will contribute to improved public health in Scotland through uptake by stakeholders in public health and the food industry.