The impact of novel crops and farming practices on the Scottish agricultural landscape



Project Lead
Challenges
Scottish agriculture is facing significant challenges associated with changing policy and markets, environment, and technology. The sector needs to maintain and increase profitability by responding to changing market conditions while simultaneously contributing to Scottish Government commitments on greenhouse gas emissions and biodiversity. These objectives must be achieved in an evolving natural environment leading to both risks and opportunities.
Technological advances are enabling proactive, preventative and resource use efficient crop management. Combined with new production technologies, these are opportunities to boost performance and profitability whilst maximising opportunities to support ecosystem services and reduce the environmental footprint of the agricultural sector. Underpinning these changes is a need to exploit genetic diversity and accelerate the efficient breeding of crop cultivars adapted to new growing technologies and environments.
This period of rapid change will have a profound impact on Scottish agriculture, affecting how we grow crops and what we grow. It will also affect how we use our land to deliver public goods, such as biodiversity and carbon sequestration. The sector covers a vast range of activity from small croft holdings to large arable and mixed farms with varying land and climate characteristics, capacity for innovation and access to capital. Farmers need to adapt to their specific growing environment, market need, capability, and capacity. Different actors will require different solutions and government policy will have different impacts across the sector. It is vital, therefore, that we understand the factors driving change in farming practice across scales and environments and identify the barriers preventing innovation.
Questions
Solutions
The project explores the factors driving change in farming practice across scales and environments and identifies the barriers preventing innovation, specifically the social and economic pressures on innovation in crops and novel production systems. This scope is on multiple levels to characterise technological lock-ins to the introduction of novel crops and cropping systems in Scottish agriculture.
Barriers and drivers for innovation in novel crops and production systems
We are investigating opportunities for change in Scottish agriculture with a focus on the drivers of current farming systems, and the barriers to the development of new ones. Adopting a multi-level perspective with a focus on co-evolution processes, the research seeks to characterise technological lock-ins to the introduction of novel crops and cropping systems in Scottish agriculture. The research comprises a desk-based study of the evolution of Scottish agriculture complemented by interviews with key stakeholders. Quantitative, longitudinal analysis of data sets provides insights into the evolutionary trends of Scottish agriculture. Research focuses on examining how the ‘niche’ - where novel crops and farming systems emerge – manages current barriers imposed at the landscape level.
Tools and technologies to accelerate novel crop development and production systems
We are developing exemplar projects to deliver practical insights into novel crop and technology development appropriate to Scottish agricultural systems. Heritage cereal varieties can provide environmentally adapted, high-value crops for specific Scottish farming communities. Barley (including bere), oat and rye landraces, are being distributed across our crofter network to examine germplasm responses to specific environments. This information is identifying genetically adapted genotypes to support revitalised cereal growing in Scottish crofting communities promoting the diversification of value chains.
Controlled environment agriculture has the potential to play a significant role in the Scottish agricultural landscape by exploiting an abundance of renewable energy. Working with vertical farming (VF) providers we examine mechanisms to improve production efficiency and enhance the nutritional and sensory quality of existing VF crops to reduce costs and improve returns. We explore integration with current cropping systems by testing the feasibility of VF for crop propagule production to reduce imports and bolster local production providing new opportunities in Scotland’s rural communities. Another project is establishing the baseline energy use, greenhouse gas emissions and inputs/outputs for VF and comparing them to alternative and established production systems.
Tools and technologies to advance breeding for novel crop use for Scotland’s farming future
We are exploring the efficiency of advanced breeding methods for rapidly repurposing under-researched crops from a Scottish perspective, to support future farming systems and evolving markets. We focus on perennial ryegrass and winter wheat as these varieties are rare despite being specifically adapted for Scottish production and have limited genetic diversity deployed for current and novel uses. For both crops, our objectives are local environmental adaptation and lower input production, to support diversity, climate resilience, production efficiency and sustainability.
Impact of novel crops and systems on rural economies and wider society
Lastly, we look to understand how novel crops and systems impact rural economies and wider society. This includes the acceptability and impact of novel crops and farming systems on local supply chains, communities, and social relations. We investigate consumers’ acceptance of novel foods within a specific territory and develop exploratory scenarios to assess the impacts of novel crops and farming systems on the territory and along supply chains, allowing evaluation of market potential and informing market interventions and policy decisions.
Project Partners
Progress
2022 / 2023
This project is a collaboration between social and natural scientists where analysis of barriers and drivers for innovation in novel crops (Work Package/WP 1) informs work to facilitate novel crop development (WP2/3), in turn providing data for understanding the impacts of novel crop systems on rural and wider society (WP4). An analytical framework to understand barriers and drivers based on socio-technical transition theory and foresight methodology was shared with WP leaders for feedback. The revised framework was provided to Rural and Environment Science and Analytical Services (RESAS) advisors and is being implemented to deliver a literature review, quantitative analysis and report.
Natural sciences research focusses on management and breeding for exemplar novel crop systems. Following engagement at citizen science kick-off workshops a network of 16 crofts was created and Bere trails conducted and analysed allowing the selection of lines for specific environments in year two. The network also provided feedback for needs for a participatory breeding app and a report has been produced and shared. Legume field trails have quantified biological nitrogen fixation and yield of dwarf early ripening faba bean and early ripening '000' soybean varieties. A key factor limiting productivity in vertical farming is the capacity of crops to use low intensity light. Lettuce, basil and pak choi genotypes wIth contrasting light use efficiency were identified and photochemical mechanisms defined as the key limiting factor. Divergent chemical and sensory traits were also recorded. Elevated CO2 enhanced photosynthesis even under low light and this valuable information has been reported to stakeholders to help them improve production efficiency.
Breeding activities, focussed on the development of locally adpated rygrass and wheat, proceeded as anticipated. In reygrass a selection of 26 diverse founders for corssing programmes were sourced and previously obtained data used to simulate crosses to direct a crossing programme. In wheat, a field trail of 640 Multi-parent Advanced Generation Inter-Crosses (MAGIC) lines was assessed fro variation in plant growth and development, including seed set, supported by remote sensing. Project activity was presented at two crop opend days in East Lothian and Lanark as part of discussion about efficient crop production with Scottish Government. In year 2, data from more extensive glasshouse trails in ryegrass and field trails in wheat will be collated and analysed.
Previous Projects
Related Projects
Improving Primary Produce
The quality of Scottish primary produce is a critical attribute for Scottish producers as it differentiates their products in crowded markets and attracts premium prices. The diversity of these food products (from crops to shellfish) can be crucial for the sustainability of rural communities. They also contribute health benefits within the diet of Scottish consumers and are of key importance to the health, and wealth, of the nation.